Second Update: I have closed comments on this post. They were getting seriously evil. No sense in giving that a platform.
Please note: many of the comments posted by readers are quite graphic. I decided to post them as is.
A lot of blog posts are about cultural or news events. A great many are about family life, education, and home improvement or craft projects. Some are about saving money. Many are about abstract theological points, or one's understanding of Scripture.
This one is not about any of these. This is about the intensely personal moment that being pro-life, and making an honest-to-God pro-life decision, reached and out grabbed me by the heart and clutched hard.
My Dark-Haired Daughter, who suffers from bipolar disorder and limited cognitive abilities, went missing last Monday. For more than 48 hours, we had no idea where she was. Without all the gruesome details, after she was found, it came to light that she'd been brutally and repeatedly sexually assaulted. She'd been taken to the local women's shelter, where (at least in our area) they do the exams in such cases.
After the police called me to tell me she'd been found, the officer asked me to meet him at the clinic and be reunited with my daughter. When I arrived, I was led to the Gloria Steinem Conference Room. I'm not kidding; that alone almost made me pass out.
In this softly lit room, with plush furniture and antique reproduction prints of ladies in hoop skirts on the wall, the counselor and the police detective filled me in on what had occurred with my daughter. I wasn't allowed to see her yet; the nurse was still completing the exam.
I sat and waited with the officer, in this softly lit room, with old magazine and the smell of flop sweat, hoop-skirted ladies looking on.
Finally, the nurse came out. She briefly and clinically told me of the injuries my daughter had, what the nurse had done to collect evidence, and that my daughter was so severely injured, the nurse thought the best course of action was to go to the emergency room so my daughter - my lovely, incredible, sweet, mentally ill daughter - could get further medical attention.
The nurse told me the antibiotics she'd administered, that we'd need to wait some time for HIV testing, and then handed me a box - Plan B, and told me we had 24 hours to use it.
So there it was. The whole moral conundrum of abortion in a little green box in my hand.
I am wholly sure I am capable of murder. I know it to the very core of my being. If the being that had done this to my daughter had been in front of me at that moment, I likely would have killed the bastard.
But Plan B is a whole other thing, isn't it? It's about taking the life of an innocent child.
Don't think I didn't think about it. Don't think that I didn't want to grab a cup of cool water, hold it to my precious daughter's lips and say, "Here; take this." Don't think I didn't want to never even think of the possibility that pregnancy would result (and still may). Don't think I didn't want to spare my daughter the burdens of dealing with a pregnancy from these circumstances.
But I shoved that green box in my bag. It's still there...unopened.
I know many, many people - some who call me friend - will think this is a monstrous decision. I should have just had her swallow the pill and never looked back. There - done. One less thing to worry about.
My daughter, though, you see, is adopted. For all I know, she herself is the product of rape. Her birth mom was known to prostitute herself, and for women in that life, rape is common.
And even if this wasn't the case, what child deserves to die due to a parent's sins and brutality? Taking an innocent life is wrong - I know it, and every genuinely honest person on the face of the earth knows it.
But I thought about it. God help me, I thought about it.
Despite my desire to murder, despite my desire to never think about the possibility of pregnancy, despite the burden of this whole experience: I am pro-life.
Gloria Steinem and her softly-lit room be damned.

God bless you for your courage in not giving in to temptation! You are a true pro-life witness: even in the face of such a terrible situation, you didn't give in to the possibility of murder for the sake of less consequences. My prayers are with your daughter and your family as you recover from this horrific situation. Thank you also for you courage in posting about this. God bless, and once again, my prayers are with your family.
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, I am grateful your daughter was found, and an so very, very sorry for what happened to her. She has been and will continue to be in my prayers, as will you...you will probably have nearly as many nightmares as a result as she will.
ReplyDeleteThe courage and faith it takes to make the decision you did is commendable, but more important is that you were able to just allow the Holy Spirit to guide you. Isn't He such a wonderful failsafe? In times of trial, it is so good to know we can fall back on the teachings of Mother Church.
God Bless you, and your sweet daughter. I will pray for her healing of mind, body and spirit.
I found you on New Advent (I think) and the subtitle caught my attention. We have a son with cystic fibrosis and another one on the way that we think has it (5 in between, too). I blog about living our Faith with children's terminal condition, but ... you and your daughter's story has stopped me in my tracks. I will add my prayers to the others'.
ReplyDeleteLove, Allison
I'm so sorry your daughter was attacked. I hope her attacker is brought to justice.
ReplyDeleteYou made an amazing, heroic decision. Thank you.
You and your family have my most fervent prayers!
ReplyDeleteYour heart is beautiful. You are willing to accept and love life, even when it reminds you of horror. I have bipolar II. I have the emotions and inclinations of bipolarity within myself. Bipolar can make a lovely, beloved, worthy soul. But she needs you. God bless you, and I'm praying for you and your daughter.
ReplyDeleteJoseph Anthony
May God be with you. You are in my prayers
ReplyDeleteAs a writer, one hates to say "words fail me", but they do. Thank you all for your kind words and support. All glory to God.
ReplyDeleteGod bless you and may God hold your daughter in a special part of His heart. May this all turn out for the best. It's moments of decisions like that that make a real hero. You have lived up to the prayer of St. Francis: "Lord, make me an instrument of your peace."
ReplyDeleteI found you on google, and you have an amazing, and sweet heart. May God bless you and your daughter. You are in my prayers.
ReplyDeleteI came here via Facebook and LifeSite. I weep for you, for her, for the terrible decision you had to make. I honor your wisdom, and I pray for justice. (I'd really like to pray for vengeance, but I know I need to be better than that.)
ReplyDeleteYou were faced with a horrific decision, to "walk the walk", or not. This post floored me. I will be praying for you both.
ReplyDeleteElise, very sorry about the assault on your daughter. But it horrifies me that you apparently did not have good information about how Plan B does and doesn't work:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.allourlives.org/node/234
What a fabulous reply! I wish I could like this! Btw, Elise: plan B works up to five days after the unprotected sex--it's just barely not too late!
DeleteGod bless you and your family, Elise. Thank you for sharing about such a tragic event and your thoughts surrounding it. I know you from the farm and will continue to keep you and your family in prayer. Praise be Jesus Christ - who I know is the grace behind your words and actions.
ReplyDeleteAmy
Well done, good and faithful servant. The Holy Spirit guided you....I am forever changed reading your story. You all are in our prayers!!
ReplyDeleteI really hope god can protect the amount of pain, emotional damage, and regret your daughter will face if she did become pregnant.
ReplyDeletegood luck with that relationship, mom.
Don't need "luck", nor do I believe in it.
DeleteI don't think she needs the type of "luck" that subscribes to the theory that any human life, no matter how inconvenient or abhorrent the manner of conception, is disposable.
DeleteWe are truly blessed to have people who not only believe, but truly believe and follow through on doing the RIGHT THING rather than take the easy way out, even though it would result in the death of an innocent unborn child.
I too am a victim of rape. It is one of the worst feelings a woman can experience. This child has been through that, and hers was not a coercion rape, but a violent one where not only was she hurt psychologically, but physically as well. I can say this without flinching and without a doubt that had she conceived a child from this horrible event, that at least it is free of any sense of guilt on the parts of those who would be the child's mother and grandmother.
The only bloodstains are those on the hands of the horrible man who raped this innocent child.
You don't seem to need science, either. Plan B doesn't abort embryos. It's essentially a super-dose of hormonal birth control. Way to traumatize your child because you insist on ignorance.
Deleteyou've got to be kidding me. how is forcing your DISABLED daughter to have a rape-baby HEROIC? for fucks sake.
ReplyDeleteYou are a fucking awful terrible person. Shame on you for making such a selfish stupid ignorant decision at the expense of YOUR DAUGHTER'S MENTAL AND PHYSICAL HEALTH.
ReplyDeleteWow, you're forcing a child with mental disabilities to become pregnant and have a child?
ReplyDeleteThere's something to be said for a person who'd assault a rape victim a second time by forcing them to become pregnant and carry it to term, and it's nothing favorable.
Furthermore, if an action like this is pleasing to your god, I'm infinitely relieved that I am not a Christian.
Published all - supportive and not. It's sure interesting to see what those who think they support women think. By the way, my daughter told me she is glad she was not given Plan B. She said the nurse at the clinic "lied to her" and she did not want to kill a baby.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteHere you go! Trying to get to all the comments. Sorry I wasn't fast enough for you. Had a lot to deal with.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteBecause I'm sure she hasn't been brainwashed by you.
DeleteChristians in America make me sick. I used to be one, but turned away because I was sick of you Pharisees. You braggarts who pray loudly in the temple so that everyone can hear. You don't give a fuck about Christ, you just care about your own egos and the idols you make of your preachers/favorite hate-mongering political regressive of the week.
How is this helping your daughter or humanity. It is making your daughter's suffering into a golden star for you, something you can smile serenely about while the awed whispers follow you as you walk in the service. You are just using this, like all other fundamentalist do, to make an idol of what you see in the mirror because of your "righteousness" while REAL LIVE children in your community starve and go hungry. But you can't do anything because it's oh-so-more important you rush off to Bible Study #3 of the week to have other well-off, middle class housewives fawn over your "righteousness".
If you cared about Christ at all you would leave the Babylon that is the modern American Christianity and actually do something to better the world.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteActually, she left her school, and yes, we are investigating how that happened. She didn't "disappear", she was abducted and held against her will.
DeleteWhether she is pregnant or not, she will always remember what occurred; how would the death of an innocent child change that for the better?
Have you checked out Marysia's link? Plan B is not actually anything like an abortion. It is a form of contraception. A preventative measure, if you will.
DeleteBtw, that was particularly venomous of me and did not serve my point in the way I first imagined. Please allow me to start again: I am deeply sorry about all that your daughter went through. That being said I wish with all of my heart that you would reconsider.
DeleteIf it occurs after conception, its an abortion. I don't care what kind of spin you put on it life begins at conception. A child has a gender from the very second that the egg meets sperm.
DeleteWere I to be raped (again) tomorrow, I would likewise refuse Plan B, Ella and anything else that would cause my body to reject an already fertilized, already male or female zygote.
I am certain that there are many other rape survivors who would and have said exactly the same thing.
I read your blog post and interview on LifeSite, and am in awe of your heart, spirit, and love for your daughter. A lot of lives are being changed by what you so bravely posted. You, and your family will continue to be in my prayers and heart.
ReplyDeleteI can understand a mother wanting to care for her child. Logically, though, failing to prevent pregnancy in a bipolar woman can be much worse than just giving her the Plan B. I assume she is on meds: those will have to changed, either stopped entirely or cut down. Taking the meds while pregnant has been known to cause miscarriages and birth defects, some fatal. Being off the meds, however, and being hormonal in addition to bipolar can seriously aggravate the condition, especially suicidal ideation.
ReplyDeleteIt's not an easy choice. But if it were me, I would risk losing a potential baby instead of risking the lives of both my daughter and her baby.
You are an awful person. Shame on you.
ReplyDeleteI'll preface this by saying that I'm sure you'll delete this post because people like you are all the same on the internet: you don't to hear insults about, or even criticisms of, your beliefs. And I'm sure that similar-minded people will click on the link on my name and send me nasty tweets- to which I say, do your worst, because I frankly don't care what somebody who will probably never meet me in real life has to say to me. So here it goes:
ReplyDeleteYou are a cunt of the highest order. And that is not a word I throw around lightly, since it's one of the worst things you can call anybody. I've never called anyone that, and you have the honor of being the first. Furthermore, your version of Christianity (I assume you're an evangelical Christian since they all hold uniformly awful beliefs like yours) is mean, spiteful, judgmental, and damaging to our society. Although I am not a Christian, I do believe that it is a beautiful religion that has the ability to teach people to be good to each other. You and other evangelicals are not good Christians; you're not even good people. You are harmful even to the ones you love, as you bragged about in this screed, and you wish to push your cult-like beliefs upon everyone, even when a healthy majority of people in this country think otherwise (see the "fetal personhood" ballot measure in Mississippi, of all states, that was soundly defeated by the voting public). I believe in a loving, kind God who looks down upon people who put others, like your daughter, through meaningless suffering. When you and the rest of your so-called "saved" militants are judged, He will not see all of you eye to eye- and I have faith in this.
How dare you insult anyone on this Earth with terrible word! The world needs less people like you, and more like the amazing person who shared this powerful and inspirational story!
DeleteOh, I guess my comment is subject to your approval before anyone else can see it. Well, disapprove it and this comment if you want. Frankly, I don't care. You are an awful cunt and the world is better off without people like you. Fuck off.
ReplyDeleteYou do realise Plan B prevents pregnancy, it doesnt kill a fertilized embryo?
ReplyDeleteMight I just say, "Where evil abounds, grace abounds all the more." Are you adding to the grace, or the evil?
ReplyDeletePlan B does NOT interfere with pregnancies after they have occurred. Unless, of course, you also believe that nobody should be allowed access to condoms, which is likely for people like you. Plan B merely prevents an egg from being fertilized and, in many cases, prevents ovulation, much like the average birth control.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.cecinfo.org/UserFiles/File/MOA_FINAL_2011_ENG.pdf
I would like to add that you are probably one of the most ignorant people I've ever seen. I hope you do not cause your daughter more pain in the future as a result of the massive amount of ignorance you hold, but I have absolutely no doubt that you will. You do not deserve to be a mother, and I hope that, somehow, some way, any young children you have are quickly taken to a place where they will be loved by a person who would put their quality of life and health above their personal beliefs. I pray that you bring no harm to anybody else because of your idiocy.
Who would want you to choose death, Elise? The evil
ReplyDeleteone. Some of these commenters are followers of him. Calling you names that defile a human being is totally evil.
You helped your dear daughter to not kill her own child and your grandchild. I pray Sts. Dymphna & Benedict Joseph LaBorra to help your Dear Dark Haired Manic Depressive Daughter through Our Dear Lord Jesus Christ